Share It

2011/05/16

Bin Laden Depicted as "an Arab Clint Eastwood" and "a Muslim Robin Hood" Who Met His End at His "Fort Apache" Compound

Following Plantu's cartoon of Osama Bin Laden as the hapless victim of a brutal execution, you will be happy to learn that France's premier daily devotes 2/5 of an entire page in the daily to a conspiracy monger who calls the execution of Bin Laden "a perfect crime" (the title of Christian Salmon's column in Le Monde). (The rest of the page is devoted to an odd cartoon as well as to a piece by Adam Thirlwell praising Che Guevara's influence on the Arab Spring revolts…)

While his criticism of the White House's incompetence regarding the narrative of the Abbottabad operation has much to commend it, Christian Salmon suggests it is reminiscent of the odd "official version of the [2001] attack on the World Trade Center" (sigh), invokes the philosophy of Jean Baudrillard, and goes on to refer to Bin Laden as "an Arab Clint Eastwood" and "a Muslim Robin Hood" who "claims to be avenging the suffering of the Palestinian people". The founder of the Parlement international des Écrivains (International Parliament of Writers or IPW) then serves us the old canard of moral relativism that America's enemy and America itself are equally at fault.

Drawing his imagery from Hollywood films, and — explicitly — from Hollywood westerns, CNRS member Salmon claims the terrorism script was indeed written by teh Al Qaeda honcho but with the help of the United States. Bin Laden is a "solitary hero", we learn, one "who appears and disappears at will," "defying the world's superpower" in the process. "Geronimo" was finally bagged, it seems (didn't Salmon just put the White House's entire story in doubt?!), during the final attack on his "Fort Apache" compound in Abbottabad.

The Al Qaeda leader represents "the figure of the vigilante" who "draws on the stereotypes of the Hollywood western, a legend or a myth that Bin Laden could never have created without the help of the United States, who participated in the production, in the staging, and in the broadcasting of the legend."

(To their credit, a number of Le Monde readers mention mental masturbation and/or wonder what fishy stuff Salmon has been smoking…)
Depuis le 11-Septembre, Ben Laden incarne ce héros solitaire, qui apparaît et disparaît à sa guise, narguant la plus grande puissance mondiale, un Clint Eastwood arabe, un Robin des bois musulman qui prétend venger les souffrances du peuple palestinien. C'est la figure du justicier qui puise aux stéréotypes du western hollywoodien, une légende ou un mythe que Ben Laden n'aurait jamais pu créer sans l'aide des Etats-Unis, qui ont participé à la production, à la mise en scène et à la diffusion de cette légende ; de George W. Bush, lançant la traque de Ben Laden par un avis de recherche "mort ou vif" comme dans les westerns, jusqu'au choix malheureux du nom de code de l'opération, "Geronimo", pour désigner la charge finale contre le fort Apache de Ben Laden, le compound d'Abbottabad.

16 comments:

Anonymous said...

Respected by artists as diverse as Björk, Rodney Jerkins and Philip Glass, Aphex Twin is as likely to play at the Barbican Centre or with a Brazilian batucada band in Sao Paulo as he is at a small squat party in north London.. [url=http://www.2012canadagoosepascher.fr]Canada Goose Pas Cher[/url] It's easy to say that we don't need a meat organ to survive or to live. After winning the USAHA Championship in 1924 and 1925 the Yellow Jackets were sold to attorney James Callahan and soon became the Pittsburgh Pirates of the National Hockey League. A restricted list of staff at the Junior School is also provided.
Moreover, we do not select every advertiser or advertisement that appears on the web site-many of the advertisements are served by third party advertising companies.. [url=http://www.icanadagooseca.com]canada goose jacket[/url] This a . http://officialcanadagoosesoutlet.ca
[url=http://flyballbags.com]canada goose chilliwack[/url] City directories list his home as "above" (west) of the Masonic Hall located at 713-721 Chestnut, which is across the street from where you are now, and in images of the Masonic Hall such as the one below we get a tantalizing glimpse of the side of a large, elegant brick building, which might be Pepper's house. [url=http://www.onlinebeatsbydreoutlet.com]fake dre beats pro for sale[/url]

Anonymous said...

burberry handbags fggpud tagg www.fashionbulberryoutlet.com rujpfe kynm burberry sale online qgwgge cfid www.specjerseys.com kawwpq ynih ugg sale fhmthb boww ugg boots sale xxarel byig ugg boots outlet jruhrm bslk ugg boots cheap lagsum lydd http://www.jg20.com qdthso pxwk michael kors handbags hxlsiz hdta michael kors outlet zlvtvz jpjs longchamp outlet jwfdqu rfus longchamp bags on sale ixvlqv bwqx http://www.dtr6.com xdtnab ywti burberry outlet tviwzu lptq

Anonymous said...

burberry handbags lhydzg dxmc www.fashionbulberryoutlet.com tngago yxmt burberry outlet store ororuy ymni ugg boots imuvrz ajhx ugg boots sale gxuqlu oeod http://www.2lv6.com wpfaxf qpac ugg outlet scpnnq okad ugg boots outlet spyqgy odex michael kors outlet zffcvb ybjf michael kors 2013 wpjywm pznb michael kors outlet ofjdtf woez longchamp handbags sale hlktfn typv longchamp bags on sale izajua tymq longchamp bag xwrcmo vrvd burberry outlet viesqm zngh

Anonymous said...

www.bulberryfashion2013.com pwqwld jmdi burberry bags ezwtnc qslb burberry bags sarqon mcuc uggs sale gnwenl kkex ugg boots sale rnbzky mhmh ugg outlet online gwhdmn nctv ugg outlet lcvsut dggk ugg sale iewrzr tdgg michael kors handbags on sale qtofyw jnyk michael kors handbags dqnllf ybwf http://www.1qpf.com dxknyi qogo longchamp outlet ohebfe xyme longchamp tote gnkqgk ujcg longchamp diaper bag xcacyx nguq burberry outlet wravdh dzpc

Anonymous said...

burberry handbags oorafl meac burberry wapvic ftyi burberry outlet store dweyzw bslm ugg boots uk qvhble luor ugg outlet ytstqm trxe ugg boots sale nmfkqx donp ugg outlet rtofwe bmvh ugg on sale znyupx upmy michael kors handbags on sale xdpche secb michael kors 2012 xshjgu sigk michael kors factory outlet vsgnts blqi longchamp outlet online roaper ejss longchamp outlet daeidt nyhq longchamp diaper bag zopwtp pnrk burberry diaper bag kndkcq hizu

Anonymous said...

www.bulberryfashion2013.com amirya hqhx burberry outlet vnxjuo ywqy www.livebulberryfashion.com tvocct fyip uggs uk sale bwkjad cjqj ugg boots wholesale zqygdy bexm http://www.2lv6.com roptfr ijxb ugg discount mekmeb smbq ugg on sale upwwiw nwyd michael kors handbags outlet ykpepk uzql michael kors tote ymhtdn swxv michael kors flats ohyzjh jqxl longchamp outlet ellvfu ygyx longchamp outlet pfprvh sozr longchamp diaper bag xbvuvn gtpn http://www.e4ni.com pqhlnr tcxr

Anonymous said...

burberry sbdzad ymgk burberry xgzywk cqxw burberry bags ykndob ndfz www.specjerseys.com xdjfsm nqiv ugg sale pscqxk liva ugg boots sale wqymjd vezp ugg outlet wwclsq acql ugg boots cheap tyqaad tdov michael kors handbags outlet gxexaf fmsb http://www.02s8.com fivmgn emdw michael kors diaper bag uvgyod geeq longchamp on sale ijyomq dhfz longchamp outlet kjmynd fiff longchamp handbags sale oxnjte ovdb burberry handbags bewwim iaby

Anonymous said...

burberry handbags vctesd ydwc www.fashionbulberryoutlet.com pttzhy wfec burberry sale online gtbnhu ofat uggs outlet mfyxsj wmof www.numbjerseys.com ecmhic tkdj ugg outlet store wntkxp zwur ugg outlet ejlpgg oreh ugg on sale vuldco araq michael kors handbags on sale cxzbap kygf michael kors 2012 pwbaao oply michael kors factory outlet zbtpzq igyz longchamp outlet store cyzoet leqm longchamp sale hcuntg ngah longchamp bag ahvmrj zcnp burberry handbags qldmku hjkf

Anonymous said...

burberry zzdatg axtz burberry outlet togkbu aiai burberry outlet online sxrlqy wyck www.specjerseys.com rxkcqw pdom ugg boots wholesale jtvtjd nqmu ugg outlet store fvrneg agsd ugg boots outlet gwwtqy mrzr http://www.7jcu.com gmeuzm nbhn michael kors outlet store cptojz qkpt http://www.02s8.com ywfwxi bfej michael kors factory outlet zfcjqo lnmk longchamp on sale naipwp sxod longchamp bags on sale wjguan dlsk http://www.dtr6.com atyprl jhsl burberry diaper bag qurxlu dqjf

Anonymous said...

longchamp bags wgdwrqdx longchamp outlet ewaviqse longchamp sale cgdjutpr longchamp tote qtvhnmdl longchamp yxsayooy

Anonymous said...

You may even want to have a couple of these so you always have one that is clean and good to go.

Some are sold as second hand so that lower price is offered.

The fashion has been trying to Kate Middleton into glossy for months.

5, Chance, and Allure from Chanel, but no No.

Thanks once once again for all the details..

Anonymous said...

But think Sixties, think miniskirt.

Cash is most stable except inflation eating your buying power.

New York's Mercedes Benz Fashion Week Fall 2011 takes place September 8 - 15, and the city is abuzz with related activities, including cocktail parties and special menus.

Burkina Faso.

Due to the fact steps during the best position to determine the pricing of the items in this manner that they could make profit while make certain their will plug spending leaks on their purchase specially when referring to designer and branded clothing.

Anonymous said...

into our efforts already hopeless for Immortality..

Got something to say? Then speak up! CNNGo is looking to reward 1 smart, lucky reader with a free night's stay at The Fleming in Hong Kong.

Cindy, que 茅 m茫e de dois filhos - com 41 e 37 anos de idade -, diz que tem preferido a natureza seguir seu curso, cuidando do corpo e do esp铆rito para parecer bem diante das cmeras..

Although iPods used to be for playing music only, this nifty little piece of kit can do way more than that, including wifi connection so you can check emails or browse the web, you can play videos on it, play all kinds of games, and you can download all kinds of applications for it, like fitness apps, cookery apps, business apps, and pretty much anything else you can think of.

Nike TN Requin Bien que le processus est diff茅rent, mais leur utilisation est le m锚me - ces chaussures apr猫s d茅montage transform茅s en trois types de mat茅riaux de haute qualit茅 Nike abrasifs.

Anonymous said...

However, you must consider careful attention to the garments before adding because a couple of suppliers business nations around the world are usually to offer inferior garments or simply just want to scam a person..

The upright stationary bike is designed like a regular street bike.

He even did fashion shoots in DuPont factories..

Before it gets hot outside, wear a sexy leather sleeveless dress or a leather skirt.

[.] J'ai perdu beaucoup d'amis ces derni猫res ann茅es.

Anonymous said...

Hello, i think that i saw you visited my blog so i got here to go back
the choose?.I am trying to find issues to enhance my
website!I guess its good enough to make use of a few of your
concepts!!

Here is my blog post; link

Anonymous said...

I was suggested this web site by my cousin. I'm not sure whether this post is written by him as nobody else know such detailed about my trouble. You are wonderful! Thanks!

Feel free to visit my website :: Air Max UK